2021 – a year in review: Looking ahead to 2022

PDP_Happy New Year 2022

As 2021 draws to a close, Richard Pigott, Director of Planning & Design Practice looks back to review what has certainly been an interesting year, and looks ahead to the opportunities of 2022.

It’s been another eventful year in the world of the built environment and, closer to home, for Planning & Design itself. The appetite to develop land and buildings or, for many people, make better use of what we have has led to continued strong demand for planning and architectural services.

The Planning White Paper, published in August 2020, promised the biggest shake-up of the planning system since the Second World War. However, there has been a re-think following the Tories’ Chesham and Amersham by-election defeat where planning dominated the campaign, with the electorate concerned that the proposed changes would make the planning system less democratic with less opportunities for communities to participate. There is a general consensus that the system needs to change but a good place to start would be to better fund local planning departments. They have struggled to cope with the perfect storm of ever-tightening purse strings, Covid-related impacts on working schedules and practices and a significant upturn in numbers of planning applications, meaning decision timescales are impossible to predict.

After the pandemic in 2020 (and, alas, this seemingly never-ending story has a few more chapters to run), perhaps the biggest news story of 2021 has been the climate emergency. Whilst we, in the UK, are not on the frontline of extreme weather it is affecting our lives right here, right now. The debate reached a fever pitch when the UK hosted the 26th UN Climate Change Conference of the Parties (COP26) in Glasgow in the autumn. But how did the conference perform? Is 1.5 (degrees) still alive? And do we now have reason to be optimistic on climate change? According to the general consensus, some significant gains were made but they were not as game changing as many hoped for. This is perhaps not surprising when the leaders of two of the biggest emitters, China and Russia, did not even attend the conference. As COP26 drew to a close, warming of under 2 degrees is potentially in reach, and almost 90 per cent of global emissions are now covered by a net-zero target.

At a policy level, whilst some local planning authorities are adopting their own supplementary planning documents on tackling climate change, Local Plans are often weak or sometimes even silent on the matter and its disappointing to see how little the revised version of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) addressed the climate emergency when it was published in July. This is out of step with public opinion – latest opinion polling by Opinium shows that 66% of people are in favour of connecting planning rules to climate change targets, so that all new development needs to pass tests to make sure they are environmentally friendly. Furthermore, first-hand experience tells me that local councillors are now considering the issue in virtually every decision they make. So, there are clear signs that the political will to ‘do something’ at the local level is gathering momentum even where the policy justification lags behind.

On another positive note, the Environment Act 2021 has recently been passed into law and this will, amongst many other things, from November 2023 require all planning permissions larger than householder permissions to deliver 10% biodiversity net gains (BNG) in as part of the overall development. If there is no scope to provide the relevant net gains on-site, then developers will be able to deliver off-site compensation through local habitat creation.

Again, many local authorities are not prepared to wait another 2 years for this to happen and we are encouraging our clients to deliver 10% BNG wherever possible.

For PDP, we have had an eventful year and more details can be found on the News page on our website. Particular highlights for me include the successful appeal for the extension to Denby Hall Business Park. This was a lengthy public inquiry, and we were able to demonstrate that very special circumstances did exist for development within the Green Belt, including the economic benefits of significant job creation and retention. At Ashbourne Airfield, work on the construction of the new link road is nearly complete, paving the way for the development of around 8 hectares of employment land and hundreds of new homes in phase 1 alone. Also, on the outskirts of Ashbourne, Callow Hall opened its doors again following a £7 million investment which we helped to achieve planning consent on over 2-3 years. Such has been the success of the project that it was awarded the Sunday Times Hotel of the Year for 2021.

On the subject of awards, we were thrilled to be Highly Commended in the recent RTPI East Midlands Awards for Excellence in Planning Delivery 2021 for our work on the Chase Farm scheme in Ambergate. A trio of our clients – Wildhive, Chevin Homes and Morley Hayes were also celebrating awards successes; the first venture for Wildhive, Derbyshire hotel Callow Hall was crowned the UK’s best place to stay by Sunday Times, Chevin Homes won ‘Residential Development of the Year’ at the East Midlands Business Link ‘Brick Awards’ 2021 for Chase Farm, and Morley Hayes carried away two awards at the 13th Derby Food and Drink Awards.

We can also celebrate the continued growth of the architectural team, reinforcing our ability to offer the complete service from concept to completion on a range of projects including bespoke Class Q barn conversions, city centre office-to-residential conversions and large-scale new housing schemes. The Sheffield office also continues to grow and consolidate its position within the Yorkshire region.

Looking towards 2022, lets hope for something a little more ‘normal’, whatever that means. We will continue to strive for ever more sustainable development and hope to see many of you in person over the next 12 months. I would like to wish you all a very Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.

Richard Pigott, Director, Planning & Design Practice Ltd

Designing affordable homes with East Midlands Homes

PDP_Affordable Homes

Planning & Design Practice Ltd are delighted to be working with East Midlands Homes in designing 33 affordable homes in Old Coppice Side, Heanor, Derbyshire.

We obtained planning permission earlier in the summer for 33 one, two and three bedroom homes on land outside the Green Belt next to Shipley Country Park. You can read more about that as this link.

Siegfried Doering, a senior member of our Architectural team is now working with East Midlands Homes to provide detailed designs and specifications for the new homes which will be available to rent by local people in housing need.

This 100% affordable housing scheme will provide much needed housing in a sustainable location next to the park. The houses will be built to a high standard with gardens, parking for cars and private amenity space.

The site is within a short walking distance of Coppice Primary School and there are local shops on Roper Avenue. The site has good access to public transport and with its proximity to the county park future residents will benefit from the wide range out outdoor activities and amenities right on their doorstep.

The homes will be built over the next two years and will help to meet the shortfall in affordable housing in Amber Valley.

We work with developers of all sizes, from small companies working on one property at a time to large housebuilders and commercial organisations where multi-million pound schemes are the norm.

We believe in good architecture. Our approachable and experienced team comprises architects, architectural assistants, designers and technicians. We offer a comprehensive design service through all the RIBA work stages from concept through to completion.

Our core planning and architectural expertise is supported by specialists in Heritage and Urban Design. We always think innovatively, and a collaborative approach is at the heart of what we do.

For more information, or to discuss how we could help with a specific project or property please don’t hesitate to get in touch.

Amber Valley – Alternative Spatial Strategy Options

PDP_Class MA, Class MA, Alternative Spacial Strategy

Amber Valley Borough Council has just issued the Alternative Spatial Strategy Options consultation that will run until the 30th of September 2021. It has also issued the Strategic Housing and Employment Land Availability Assessment (SHELAA).

The Strategy Options have two elements.

The first is the quantum of housing and the amount of employment land that should be allocated. There are three options based on a central point where they council believes they can meet both their housing and employment land needs. There is a higher figure to promote growth and a lower figure to restrict growth in the Borough. The central figure is sufficient land for 6,395 dwellings and 42.33ha of employment land. The figure for growth is land for 7994 dwellings and 54.8ha of employment land and the lower figure is 4,796 homes and 34.2ha of employment land.

All these figures should be seen in the context that in 2019 the council were committed to building 9,977 dwellings and releasing 42ha of employment land. Since 2019 the government has changed the method for calculating housing need and the requirement to take housing from Derby, effectively overspill, has gone.

We believe that Amber Valley should pursue a growth agenda, unemployment is currently 4.5% and there is a need to secure employment, particularly in manufacturing. With new jobs comes new housing as jobs and homes should be located close to each other to minimise commuting and to reduce carbon emissions.

The second element is the spatial distribution of homes and employment land. The first option is to focus growth on the edge of Derby but outside the Green Belt. The second is to disburse growth into the villages and away from existing urban areas. The third is for a major urban extension or a new settlement outside the Green Belt, while the fourth is to concentrate development around Alfreton, Belper, Heanor and Ripley and on the edge of Derby with more limited growth in villages.

The fourth option is the likely outcome, but a major urban expansion of Derby, perhaps at Mackworth and Radbourne is a reasonable other option.

It is likely that the council will end up seeking to take the middle course but there will be pressure to limit development and it is important that we are seen to pursue a growth agenda.

The SHELAA is available on the Council’s web-site and it shows which sites have been considered and those considered suitable. It is likely that the quantum of land will broadly meet the middle option.

Jonathan Jenkin, Consultant, Planning & Design Practice Ltd

Outline Permission for 35 New Dwellings in South Wingfield

PDP_South Wingfield

South Wingfield lies about 2 miles west of Alfreton in Amber Valley. It is a village of over 1500 inhabitants with a good primary school, a doctor’s surgery, shops, and community facilities.

Amber Valley is under great pressure to find housing land to meet its own housing needs and some of Derby’s housing, as part of an agreement with the City of Derby and South Derbyshire Councils. All parts of the Borough have to take some housing and South Wingfield as a sustainable settlement with a school short of pupils, was identified by Amber Valley as having the capacity to take a small number of additional homes.

The site, at the north end of the village was identified by the Council. The land was included in the Draft Local Plan as a housing allocation 2 years ago. The site was subject to two rounds of public consultation and was discussed at the Local Plan Examination hearings in June 2018. At the hearing there were no objections from the Parish Council and no objections from local residents. The site was not considered to be controversial.

However when the outline planning application was submitted for 35 homes there was an immediate outcry, villagers strongly objected and the Parish Council sought to resist the proposals. There were no objections from highways or other statutory consultees and the planning authority duly recommended approval.

The planning committee meeting was highly charged. We spoke in favour of the application and it was approved on the casting vote of the chairman.

In May 2019 however the council decided to ditch its emerging local plan. This changed the planning policy environment and led to the council announcing a 5 year housing land supply and the recall of this application back to planning committee for a further decision. The council was able to do this because the Section 106 Agreement had not been signed by that point and the Decision Notice had not been issued.

The application was again recommended for approval. The planning meeting was again highly charged and following 6 objectors speeches we spoke in favour of the application. The application was approved by a healthy margin.

The Council’s decision making process took 10 months on a 13 week planning application. The Section 106 is due to be signed and the Decision Notice should be issued very soon. It shows that a planning approval is never in the bag until the Decision Notice is issued.

Jonathan Jenkin, Managing Director, Planning & Design

PDP secures permission for 175 homes in Nether Heage, Derbyshire

PDP_Nether Heage

The Firs Works is a 10ha site lying on the western edge of Nether Heage about 3 miles north of Belper. The site lies outside the Green Belt but abuts it on two sides and on the third is the Derwent Valley Mills World Heritage Site Buffer Zone.

The site contains industrial and commercial buildings which were developed following the use of the land as a camp in the 1940s. The site has been excavated to accommodate the current set of buildings on the site, creating a level site on what was a sloping hillside. Most of the developed site is either buildings or hardstanding, with eaves heights of up to 10m and ridge heights of up to 12m. Surrounding the land are areas of landscaping and planting.

The site is not easily visible from Crich Lane to the west, with the buildings hidden below the excavated escarpment. To the east, the buildings sit on the crown of the hill and are prominent across Nether Heage and Heage. The site is clearly visible from Heage Windmill.

The site is accessed via a set of minor rural roads from either the A6 or from Ripley and the B6013 via Brook Street and Spanker Lane. HGV traffic has to negotiate narrow roads making the site less suited to modern industrial and commercial operations.

Use of the site has fallen away in recent years and back in January planning permission was granted for the use of the staff car park on the other side of Spanker Lane to be redeveloped for the construction of 30 homes.

The council has a shortfall in housing land (3.34 years) but no shortfall in industrial or commercial land. The council has recently adopted a policy which seeks the release of Green Belt land to accommodate their housing needs, but in doing so existing brownfield sites must be considered first in order that the minimum amount of Green Belt land released.

The application was for 175 dwellings, consisting of 2, 3, 4 and 5 bedroom homes, using the land which has already been developed. Existing buildings will be demolished and replaced by houses, bungalows and flats. The proposals include affordable housing, open space, recreation facilities and a community centre. Existing edge landscaping will be retained and strengthened with large areas of hardstanding broken up and replaced with gardens and green space. The overall level of built development will reduce and the form and massing of the buildings will be smaller. The redevelopment of this site offers the opportunity to reduce problems of surface water run-off and flooding, with new flood balancing facilities on land in the applicant’s ownership. This will reduce problems suffered by local residents in previous years. The transport statement indicated no material increase in traffic but with HGV and staff travel replaced by resident’s vehicles.

The redevelopment of the land will significantly increase the number of residents in Nether Heage, adding 40% to the village population. Heage School is about 1km away and the local secondary school is Swanwick. Both the primary and secondary school are close to capacity, requiring significant Section 106 monies for education. Other services have capacity to accommodate the development. The site can be accessed by bus and Ambergate railway station only a mile to the North West.

The site is reasonably well related to existing services and facilities and although not ideal in locational terms, the site is clearly preferable to the release of Green belt land (including a proposed release of land for 180 dwellings at Heage within a mile of this site).

The application drew significant levels of objection from local residents concerned about the scale of development. The objectors also had an issue with a perceived increase in road traffic but given that there were no objections from the County Highways Officer, little weight was given to this concern.

The application was recommended for approval (subject to the successful completion of a Section 106 Agreement to secure education and other payments and the provision of affordable housing). At committee 8 objectors spoke. Richard Pigott from Planning Design Practice then spoke in favour of the development. After significant debate, principally over the dilemma of loss of employment land, and the scale of development; the application was approved by 6 votes to 4 because of the shortfall in housing land and the need to minimise the impact on the Green Belt.

Development of this site is scheduled to start within 5 years, with reserved matters to be submitted soon. In the meantime the owner of the site will use part of the site to develop a pilot plant to extrude aluminium using the very latest technology.

Amber Valley is one of the last Local Planning Authority areas in the East Midlands without a 5 year housing land supply so remains the focus for speculative development.

Any brownfield site within Amber Valley (unless it is part of a primary employment site or has a history of contamination) is potentially suitable for housing. Also non-green belt sites if they are adjacent to towns or villages can also be considered.

Please feel free to contact us at Planning & Design Practice if you have any land in Amber Valley and are looking for development.

PDP secure planning consent for 35 new dwellings in South Wingfield

PDP_South Wingfield

South Wingfield lies about 2 miles west of Alfreton in Amber Valley. It is a village of over 1500 inhabitants with a good primary school, a doctor’s surgery, shops, and community facilities. The southern end of the village is a conservation area and this part of the village is dominated by South Wingfield Manor an important heritage asset.

Amber Valley is under great pressure to find housing land to meet it’s own housing needs and some of Derby’s housing, as part of an agreement with the City of Derby and South Derbyshire Councils. All parts of the Borough have to take some housing and South Wingfield as a sustainable settlement with a school short of pupils, was identified by Amber Valley as having the capacity to take a small number of additional homes.

The site, at the north end of the village was identified. The land was included in the Draft Local Plan as a housing allocation over 2 years ago. The site was subject to two rounds of public consultation and was discussed at the Local Plan Examination hearings last June. At the hearing there were no objections from the Parish Council and no objections from local residents. The site was not controversial.

When the outline planning application was submitted for 35 homes there was an immediate outcry, 122 letters of objection were submitted to the Borough Council and the Parish Council sought to strongly resist the proposals. There were no objections from highways or other statutory consultees and the planning authority duly recommended approval.

The meeting was highly charged. The atmosphere was hostile as sixty residents with members of the Parish Council sought to browbeat the committee and planning officers. There were 9 speakers against the application that’s 27 minutes of contentious objection. We had 3 minutes to speak in favour. 

South Wingfield Parish Council verbally attacked Councillors, in their objections speech, not something that we would ever recommend. There was an objection speech from the Local Councillor (a conservative) but she was not on Planning Committee.

Amber Valley Council are politically finely balanced and hold elections every year. It is common that the lead party supports officer recommendation but the opposition tend to vote with objectors to carry favour before the next election.

At Planning Committee there is a conservative majority of one plus the chairman and his casting vote if the vote is level.

After a rowdy debate, members voted 5/5 and the chairman used his casting vote. A win 6/5.

Solicitors are now drawing up the Section 106 Agreement. Once signed, a detailed application will follow.

This was an uncomfortable meeting, with objectors behaving poorly. 

The management and organisation of the meeting could have been better and objectors could have been told more clearly how they should behave. Without effective policing decisions can be made to please the crowd. We were pleased that this did not happen.

PDP secure planning consent for barn conversion in Amber Valley

PDP_Barn Conversion

Planning & Design Practice recently secured planning permission for a barn conversion within the Amber Valley Borough. The barn was starting to become weaker, with one wall on the rear elevation beginning to crumble and a steel bracing holding the two main walls firmly in an upright position.

We were approached by the client to prepare designs for the conversion of the building to create an aspirational dwelling in this highly sought-after location.

After a number of sketch scheme ideas, we decided on a design to maximise the space and comfortability of the building. The barn will be converted into a 2-bedroom dwelling including one with an ensuite. We also decided that the dilapidated timber extension could be demolished and re-built on the same footprint to add a contemporary touch to the barn, whilst retaining an agricultural feel.

The application achieved planning consent with minimal complications. Approval was granted in November 2018.

Project team: Lindsay Cruddas, Daryl Sanders, Rebecca Beardsley

PDP Secure Permission for New Sheep Dairy Enterprise at Historic Derbyshire Farm

PDP_Wakebridge Farm

We were delighted to obtain planning and Listed Building consent in December for the redevelopment of Wakebridge Farm, Crich, to form a sheep dairy enterprise with an associated creamery, hotel, restaurant and bar.

Wakebridge Farm is a former dairy farm including a Grade II Listed late 18th Century farmhouse and attached stone barns (all in need of restoration and repair), built by Peter Nightingale on the site of a medieval manor house and chapel. The farm sits in a small valley overlooking the Derwent Valley, within the World Heritage Site Buffer Zone. On the adjacent hillside is the Grade II* Listed Crich Stand, as well as the Crich Tramway Village, a popular tourist attraction.

Our clients, who have many years’ experience in farming and veterinary practice, wish to develop on of the first sheep’s milk enterprises of its type in the country, with an on-site creamery to produce cheese and other dairy products, and viewing platforms to allow visitors to see the whole process in action.

The old farmhouse and barns will be sensitively converted into a small hotel and restaurant (selling produce from the farm), as well as a training room for veterinary and agriculture students.

This multi-faceted proposal, in a sensitive area the subject of many restrictions and designations, required careful navigation through the planning process. We took on board the views of various consultees and adjusted the plans where appropriate, culminating in what we hope will be an exciting but neighbourly development, contributing positively to the local economy and tourist offer.

We were very pleased when the Amber Valley Planning Board unanimously voted to approve the application at their December meeting. 

If you want to know more about this project, please contact us and ask to speak to Jon Millhouse or Lindsay Cruddas.

Planning & Design Practice secure planning consent for barn conversion in Amber Valley

PDP_Amber Valley Barn Conversion

Planning & Design Practice recently secured planning permission for a barn conversion within the Amber Valley Borough. The barn was starting to become weaker, with one wall on the rear elevation beginning to crumble and a steel bracing holding the two main walls firmly in an upright position.

We were approached by the client to prepare designs for the conversion of the building to create an aspirational dwelling in this highly sought-after location. An RIBA Chartered Practice, our approachable and experienced team is comprised of architects, architectural assistants, designers and technicians, who offer a comprehensive design service from concept through to completion.

After a number of sketch scheme ideas, we decided on a design to maximise the space and comfortability of the building. The barn will be converted into a 2-bedroom dwelling including one with an ensuite. We also decided that the dilapidated timber extension could be demolished and re-built on the same footprint to add a contemporary touch to the barn, whilst retaining an agricultural feel.

The application achieved planning consent with minimal complications. Approval was granted in November 2018.

We believe that good design is a crucial part of the planning process. Getting the design of a project right is critical to gaining a successful planning consent and avoiding unnecessary delay and costs.

Our team of RIBA Chartered Architects and Architectural Assistants have a wealth of experience working with homeowners, developers and the public sector.

For more information and for a no obligation consultation to discuss your project, please call us on 01332 347371.

Amber Valley

PDP achieves consent for 100 houses in Heanor

PDP_100 Houses Heanor

Planning & Design Practice have successfully gained planning permission for 100 houses at Heanor. The site is in a sustainable location on the edge of Heanor, but outside of the Green Belt. The outline application was granted planning permission on delegated powers, subject to a Section 106 Legal Agreement for developer contributions.

Working closely with Planning Officers at Amber Valley Borough Council, any issues that arose during the consideration process were dealt with swiftly and professionally. This included a Geophysical Survey of the site to assess the potential for hidden archaeological features.

We also commissioned a specialist report from Highways Consultants to show that the existing access route and junction with the main road was suitable for the amount of traffic expected for a development of this size.

An Indicative Masterplan was produced to support the application, following the principles of good urban design, which showed that the number of houses could be laid out satisfactorily on the available land, respect the existing residential properties around the site, and incorporate suitable areas of public open space, along with sustainable drainage systems (SuDS) to deal with rainwater runoff.

The legal agreement requires financial payments to fund the provision of additional primary and secondary education places in the nearest schools, and a payment to the NHS to increase capacity at nearby doctor’s surgeries, as well as a contribution towards the enhancement of playing and sports pitches in Heanor. All of the payments agreed to are directly proportional to the number of houses on the development.

Getting a planning permission for a development of 100 homes under delegated approval is a substantial achievement and one that the company is very proud of. When we submitted the application we expected considerable opposition and there were in fact almost 70 objections, largely in relation to lack of infrastructure – school places, doctor’s surgeries etc., as well as traffic levels – however these issues were addressed by the financial contributions required by the Section 106 Legal Agreement, and a Travel Plan to encourage the use of sustainable methods of transport.

Planning & Design Practice is looking forward to the opportunity to work with any potential developer of the site on a Reserved Matters application, to resolve the finer details of the scheme and see construction start.

The approved scheme will help to address Amber Valley Borough Council’s shortfall in their 5 year supply of suitable housing land. However, the Council are still looking for more housing sites, so if you are a landowner and have land that you think may be suitable, please do not hesitate to get in touch.

GET IN TOUCH